Topic for open discussion: AWEIA
Airborne Wind Energy Industry Association |
Send
AWE notes and topic replies to editor@upperwindpower.com
|
?next? |
Feb. 23, 2021, post by Dave
Santos Airborne Wind Energy at a crossroads: Return to AWEIA Principles In
2009, before AWEurope (prev. AWEC) ever existed, there was AWEIA
(Airborne Wind Energy Industry Association), set up on "Open-AWE"
principles. Founding President Pro-Tem, John Oyebanji served bravely, a
favorite under Wubbo Ockel's cosmopolitan leadership, then snubbed by
provincialist self-serving VC insiders, after Wubbo died. The VC
insiders had formed AWEC in secret in 2010, as a California 501c4
(Industry Association), that passed into EU insider hands to rebrand as
AWEurope, which also operates in secret.
Anticipating
the temptations of AWE to seek profits over science and cut corners on
safety, AWEIA's focus was on professional ethics and safety. A
provisional AWEIA Ethics Code was adapted from Cristina Archer's
Geological Society of America. Joe an I developed TACO in 2011 as an
Aviation Safety ConOps for AWE. AWEIA worked most closely with the FAA
to gain the freedom to self-police our domain. A Makani Founder wrote,
"you are not the AWE Police". Effectively we all are.
AWE
R&D has become massively corrupted on both business and safety
fronts. The most dangerous architectures have advanced in ignorance as
rounds of large investments have raised from public and private
sources, even mislead "crowd-funding" small contributors. Safety data
has been corrupted by the non-reporting or down-playing of serious
crashes and mishaps. Some ventures even give up testing and just
produce sterile promises. About a billion dollars has been spent this
way.
AWE
Academics direct major research toward their personal IP without
diligent public disclosure, and against Optimal Experimental Design
that would vet their early a-priori down-selects. Unqualified promoters
raise huge sums from grant sources to predictably fail. AWE
Militarization has emerged as easy money extending the run of ventures
whose key milestones have long slipped and will never be met. A code of
silence has taken hold, where top insiders peddle infomercial content
without public debate. These outcomes did come from bad people, but
from a dynamic of gradual decay under steady pressure for results.
The
worst AWE ventures combine all these major flaws and control AWE
conferences and most industry PR. New or poorly connected AWE workers
are mostly unaware of the decade of backroom dealings that set up the
status quo. They are fooled by AWEurope capture of IEA, Planair, and US
DOE ARPA-E and NREL; as false official validations, while these Gov and
quasi-gov entities have no AWE expertise to judge by, but play along
flattered by unearned respect, pretending to represent US and Global
AWE R&D Communities they did not even know existed. The broad
Global AWE R&D gap is evident exclusion of India's AWE researchers,
by the class-inequity and cultural provincialism of controlling
insiders.
Guarantee
of integrity in AWE R&D is an essential requirement. Transparent
equitable international engineering-science collaboration must
prevail. It is
time to return to original AWE AWEIA principles, as we enter ever more
serious R&D rounds.
|